Skip to content

10 ways to avoid an almighty balls-up in Mailchimp

Published 29 October 2026

Graphic showing OMFG in small writing on a teal background

A little story

Earlier this week I was modifying a client’s automation sequence. It had a filter in it where we’d sent contacts down two different pathways to test something out. One version was performing better so we wanted to delete the version that wasn’t doing so well.

So I deleted the filter and told Mailchimp which pathway to retain – a seemingly simple task. But instead, Mailchimp just deleted the entire rest of the sequence including multiple emails, steps and conditions.

Luckily this was a back-up of the automation, and I was testing the change before making it on the live version. Otherwise that would have been a bloody disaster frankly. Not only would everything have needed rebuilding, but it would also have removed all the people who were going through the sequence.

Now, I don’t want you to get the wrong idea. Mostly Mailchimp is brilliant – immediately after this happened I raised it with my partner manager and their engineers are already resolving the issue. I work with a huge number of softwares and apps and none of them are perfect either.

But it did prompt me to write this blog, because after 16 years of working with Mailchimp, there’s one phrase that still makes me a bit nervous:

“I’ll just quickly change this.”

Sometimes it really is a quick change. But sometimes it’s the start of a truly stressful and awful afternoon / day / week you’d rather have spent doing absolutely anything else.

Human error happens, even if you know what you’re doing. You’re distracted, you overlook a setting, you inadvertently discover a Mailchimp “quirk” (because let’s face it, it has some!), or you discover that the seemingly insignificant thing you’ve just removed was holding something important together.

Over the years, I’ve made mistakes of my own and helped deal with a whopping number of other people’s. And a bit like drinking strawberry bubble-bath to see if it tasted as nice as it smelled (yes I did), some of these lessons have been learnt the hard way, so you don’t have to.

Here goes…

1. Export your audience before making any changes

Make this a habit: export your audience at least monthly, and always before making changes to your data.

Updating fields? Export first. Removing tags? Export first. Doing a big import and feeling entirely confident about it? Excellent. Export first anyway.

Your export gives you a snapshot of your contacts at that point, including audience fields, tags and marketing permissions and opt-in details. If you accidentally overwrite useful information, you’ve got a record to refer back to and re-update Mailchimp if you need to.

It isn’t a complete undo button, though. Audience exports don’t contain everything, including email engagement history and a complete record of profile changes. You can use them to help restore data, but you can’t simply re-import a file and expect the entire account to return to its previous state.

Download the export, date it clearly and store it securely. A backup sitting somewhere you can’t find isn’t much help when you need it.

2. Check API keys before removing users

Removing a former employee or supplier from your account is sensible.

Accidentally disconnecting your website or CRM in the process is less helpful.

When you remove a user’s access, Mailchimp also removes any API keys they created. Those keys may be connecting your account to a website form, your CRM or another important system. Remove the key and that connection can stop working.

Before removing someone, check which API keys belong to them and what those keys are being used for.

Where necessary, arrange replacement keys through an appropriate remaining user, update the integrations and test them before removing access.

It’s a small check that can save a big headache.

3. Copy your automations before changing them

A small change to an automation can have consequences well beyond the bit you’re looking at.

Changing a filter, removing a split or moving a pathway might seem straightforward. Then contacts start going somewhere you didn’t intend, or stop going anywhere at all. Or maybe you even delete a heap of emails from the sequence below that point without intending to. Trust me, it happens.

Before changing an automation’s structure, replicate it so you have an untouched copy of the original. Mailchimp’s replication feature copies the flow’s triggers, rules and actions, including its email content.

Use a separate working copy to test the proposed changes. If you activate it for testing, make sure only your test contacts can enter.

Check each route and consider what the live change will mean for people already moving through the automation.

This is one of those jobs where a bit of prep is a damn sight quicker than trying to deal with the consequences afterwards.

4. Name things so they make sense to someone else

A tag called YES probably meant something when you created it. But will it mean anything to you next March? Or to Sam in the marketing team if you go off sick for a while?

Obvious and consistent naming matters across your whole account: tags, segments, fields, campaigns, images, automations and the column headings in audience.

“Welcome series – course signups” is much more useful than “Automation 3 (copy)”.

Choose a consistent approach. Where something has a particular purpose, document it. A tag that triggers an automation needs more explanation than “I think we used that for something last year”.

Don’t assume you’ll remember. And don’t assume someone else will understand your system if you’re on holiday or no longer working in the business.

You shouldn’t need to be there and available for your account to make sense.

5. Update email links when your website changes

You’ve replaced a service page, changed your booking system or reorganised your website. But have you updated the emails pointing to it?

Check your automations and saved templates whenever website links change. Pay particular attention to buttons and linked images, where an outdated address is easy to overlook.

Your welcome email might have been sending people to that page quite happily for three years. It won’t know you’ve moved it.

Click through the links yourself and follow the process. Can someone still book, buy or download what you’ve promised?

A broken link can cost you a sale. Worse, you might never know the person tried.

6. Review your live automations at least quarterly

It’s very easy to forget what’s sending once an automation is quietly ticking along in the background. And that means it can carry on being wrong just as quietly.

At least once a quarter, look through your active automations and read what they’re sending. Check the entry conditions, timings and destinations as well as the emails themselves. Check they don’t clash with one another and you don’t have subscribers getting more than one email from different flows or scheduled sends very close together.

Are you still offering that service? Is the price correct? Has your branding or template changed? Does the email refer to someone who left six months ago? Was someone fiddling with the footer and typed a copyright year instead of leaving the merge tag to update it automatically?

Look at the results too. If an automation that normally receives a steady stream of contacts has suddenly gone quiet, investigate.

And put this review in your calendar. Otherwise it has a habit of becoming something you were definitely going to do last month.

7. Sign up to your own mailing list again

Regularly. Through the different forms dotted around the ether on your website, social, email signatures etc. To make it easier, use a fresh test address or even better an “email alias” supported by your email provider, so you can experience the process as a new subscriber.

Check what happens after you submit. Does the confirmation arrive? Does the promised download appear? Are you taken to the right page and entered into the correct welcome sequence?

Then look at your contact record in Mailchimp to check the expected information and tags have arrived.

A form looking perfectly respectable on your website tells you very little about whether it’s actually working.

8. Remove users and integrations you no longer need

Mailchimp accounts can collect a lot of clutter over the years. The agency you stopped using. The freelancer who helped with a launch. The integration you tested and forgot about. The Mailchimp IOS app someone installed on their phone before they left the company or lost it.

Review who has access and what’s connected. Establish what each integration does before disconnecting it, and check the API key dependencies mentioned earlier before removing users.

For anything you keep, make sure its purpose is clear and someone takes responsibility for it. You’ll have a better understanding of how your account works, and fewer mysteries to investigate when something goes wrong.

9. Keep an eye out for bot signups

A sudden surge in new subscribers might look exciting. But before you celebrate, check if they’re real.

A few years back a company contacted me because they were suddenly getting thousands of bot signups every minute, for hours. That caused emails to bounce, damanged their sender reputation, resulted in account warnings from Mailchimp and whopped up their bill massively.

If you’re not using double opt-in and appropriate bot protection, pay particular attention to unexpected signup spikes, strange names and suspicious patterns in new contacts.

Double opt-in (DOI) can be a bit of a pain on a day-to-day basis, but it adds a confirmation step before someone becomes subscribed. reCAPTCHA helps protect supported forms against automated submissions.

Also check how your forms connect to Mailchimp. Turning on double opt-in in Mailchimp doesn’t automatically apply it to every third-party form or API integration. Those connections may need configuring separately.

If your audience suddenly starts growing at a rate that bears no resemblance to your normal activity, make sure you know quickly, and can deal with it quickly.

10. Archive for housekeeping. Treat deletion with care.

If you’re tidying your audience, archiving should generally be your starting point.

Archiving is reversible and preserves the contact’s data. Permanent deletion removes personal information and can’t be undone.

You also can’t simply restore a permanently deleted contact back into that audience using your backup spreadsheet.

Where someone has requested erasure of their personal data and that request needs to be fulfilled, archiving isn’t a substitute for deletion because it retains their information.

For everyday audience housekeeping, though, don’t reach for permanent deletion simply because it sounds more thorough.

Give yourself a fighting chance

Need help making sense of your Mailchimp account? Book a Chimpology Power Hour and we’ll work through your questions together, with practical advice on what to fix and how to keep things running smoothly.

Got questions? Need help or advice?

Book a Mailchimp Power Hour and let's spend an hour together, working live within your account, sharing screens and going through things at your pace.

Find out about the Mailchimp Power Hour

You may be interested in...

Sender name, subject line and preview text in Mailchimp: stop wasting your inbox space

You can spend hours getting an email just right. Tweak the wording, find the perfect images, move the button, move it back again. But before someone on your mailing list sees any of that, they have to decide whether to open it in the first place. And in the inbox, you’ve only got a tinyContinue reading “Sender name, subject line and preview text in Mailchimp: stop wasting your inbox space”

Read more →